Episode 14The Psychology of Leadership and Influence

Building Teams That Share Power

Why do smart individuals so often make an underperforming team? Five foundations for a team that truly shares power.

Episode 14 — Building Teams That Share Power
In this episode
  • Why executive teams are often “over-challenged individually, under-challenged collectively”
  • Purpose: defining what only this team, not any individual, should be doing
  • Norms: the single most predictive factor of team effectiveness in real research
  • Membership: the surprising number of teams that can't agree who's actually on them
  • Decision-making: why divergence must come before convergence
  • Learning: why teams need to pause and reflect on themselves, not just their work
  • Why the best use of a manager's power is often to step out of the centre

Drs. Vinay and Paul argue that most executive teams are “over-challenged individually and under-challenged collectively” — talented people who never truly function as a team. They outline five foundations for a team that shares power well: a clearly defined shared purpose distinct from individual work, agreed norms for how members will engage (the single most predictive factor of team effectiveness in one major study), clear membership boundaries, a shared process for decision-making (divergence before convergence), and regular team-level learning and reflection. Real stories — a mystery attendee at an executive meeting, organisations removing layers of management entirely — illustrate why the best use of a manager's power is often to step out of the centre and let the team's mission lead.

Chapters

01Welcome and Episode Overview

00:00:00

02Why Smart Individuals Don't Always Make Smart Teams

00:00:21

03The Manager's Role: Help or Hindrance?

00:06:33

04From Manager-Centric to Purpose-Driven Teams

00:11:45

05The Five Foundations of Effective Teams

00:12:27

06Clarifying Team Purpose and Priorities

00:13:01

07Establishing Team Norms for Accountability

00:17:11

08Defining Team Membership and Boundaries

00:22:57

09Decision-Making and Problem-Solving as a Team

00:29:02

10Team Learning and Self-Reflection

00:31:16

11Practical Takeaways and Self-Assessment for Teams

00:33:49
Full transcript

Auto-generated transcript (speech-to-text). Speaker labels not included; minor transcription errors may be present.

Good. Well, welcome everyone to our next episode. always something interesting to talk about about power. I'm dr Stephen Agatha and here with Dr Paul Donovan We're fascinated by this topic. we enjoy talking about it And we hope its useful too. So today were going to talk About teams The difference between a cooperative and synergistic an intelligent team and Between perhaps the team where people acting more as individuals or it's not really coalescing, perhaps there are difficulties.

Perhaps the team is not so smart collectively. So Paul just take away. what do you want to say about this topic? Yeah This a topic that I have been engaging in professionally for many years and As i've got Greya an older seniority of teams working with has gotten higher. So for the last week, now that I'm very old. co-operate and getting them to sort of pull something in one direction as they want a race that go everywhere.

And there are relatively poor teams, so yet their highly motivated, highly intelligent generally speaking. but if you ask him about the team then he'll say oh I barely tolerate those meetings! In other words i hate it when we get together. Oh sure Do we have to actually ever do anything, work together talk together? I mean and in many cases if the CEO is not really hard-lined about it. they'll have. increasingly people just vote with their feet and say oh no i had a really important client meeting couldn't come to that one then.

They will just vote for their feed out of them. so yeah its real problem. And all this stuff goes on with teams. If really the bad stuff that happens with teams, if it happens there then has ricochet and ripple effects all over the organisation. And so their collective can be kind of mediocre in almost dumb. even when you've got a group of individuals who might very smart but motivated But together they become stupid.

It's just not uncommon. In fact, one of the things which I noticed is that teams often can be... The individuals can very stretched and challenged there And this was very true for more senior teens but it could be true less so as well Very like they've got whole departments underneath them. for now They're working their tail off But are they collectively challenged? Are doing anything together? often not. So there's very little collective stretch or challenge, they're over challenged individually and under-challenged collectively.

They are doing almost nothing together. You know it reminds me in some ways of like you were mentioning another time about And as often the case someone is good at their job you know, good technical person or something. and then they get promoted to management. And then the managing others. but just because they're good at their job doesn't mean that they know how to manage! They can be super skillful or super smart or super productive in there job.

But management is like a whole other level of skill. it does not automatically correlate It's bit same. I think You have lot really great people who are productive and responsible doing well and you can put them in a room, but that doesn't necessarily mean they're going to synergise as team. No it does not! I see this all the time even in sports environments...I don't know what you saw recently here in Australia. there is There is this great rugby league happening every year where New South Wales plays Queensland in the state of origin.

And it's remarkable because both teams have the best Australian talent. really, you could say some might come from other states but the vast majority will come form those two States and each team has no lack of talent. But the extent to which they can actually operate as a team will determine who wins that. And the extent in which they recover when their under pressure, whether they support one another... That we'll ultimately create and for many years actually Queensland had a far stronger sense of team.

Um..and thats why they won it Years! For years in a row Which was just stopped In this last one Where there were for breath of fresh air The New South Welsh men had a sense of shared identity for the first time, which enabled them to do something quite unique. Yeah and it's the same thing with The World Cup. I watched some of The World Cups here in China. watching was difficult because you know, once every four years I can sacrifice and so got up to what's saying.

And really actually like Spain was kind of going for them as a team. Partly they were very skillful but the way that they worked together is just incredible. it was beautiful You know, no one could guess the skill. I mean if...I think that best soccer player in world was on the opposing team you know. but yeah this is the secret. This is just as to whether a team can operate really well and this where it goes into power because most of time The role manager makes the team operate worse not better And increasingly people seem to have such little ability, to be part of a team as manager and not just get in the friggin way.

Of what a team needs to do. increasingly The future is such that really highly operating teams don't have managers. And it's one if some of the most successful organizations In the world actually are so because they're removing managers from the picture altogether. And that's, I mean you want to know more about Bill Anderson not the author who wrote Scaling Leadership but the CEO of Bayer. A massive chemical and they make headache tablets as well a whole lot other things.

He speaks very eloquently on this because he has turned around the behonoth of Baye simply by reducing bureaucracy which was created by having so many managers. And when I'm working with teams, one of the things that i look to do is consider to the extent at which manager are keeping central and communication in team as running through them or whether whether I can help the manager get out of The sender and the team Join the team And helped create forums where this Team works with one another better, and that is how a manager uses power.

Well it's to get themselves Out-of-the middle. Then what do they want replaced in? In the Middle They Want To Get the Manager out and they What the Team Purpose. in the Middle they Want Mission First in the middle of a team. And that's most effective way for managers to use their power when it comes really affective teams, is get out connect more comfortably, more frequently or easily directly with one another. So ironically it's not flexing their muscle of the power and doing things in terms of the leadership of the team.

It is actually using that power to hold a space. as we say in psychotherapy We talk about holding space. Or you run a group You're not necessarily intervening alot but your so-to speak holding this space And just judiciously stepping in. But most time work with each other? Absolutely, absolutely. And this is the future. if managers don't know how to get out of the middle then ultimately they'll get taken out because that's too costly and actually stop things happening.

I mean BERSFORG which a Danish healthcare organisation has sixteen thousand employees. They have two managers. That's it, I mean new course. steel in America is doing the same thing. Bayer has done that and there are a number of organisations now they're increasingly looking to say if managers can't actually learn not have their role as an obstacle for team really operating well creating more bureaucracy for a team to go through, then that's not helpful.

You know like so... That is why most of the organisations or people you and I are having as an audience. they're not going be doing it there. those CEOs aren't taking all management rethinking how organisation start function. So in the meantime, if you want teams to function really well and your manager learn how get out of them. In doing so probably create less bureaucracy and more ease And speed with your team. Any large organization when someone joins You can pretty much say that their efficacy, their ability to add value will drop by somewhere between fifty and seventy percent simply because they're in a large organization has massive bureaucracy.

If the same person is working at very small organisation or are working for themselves if they started working for themselfs Their productivity would double overnight. That's simply becuase. there were people who work in a larger organisation. A lot of that bureaucracy comes from managers. So, yeah. There's moving from there and making a team that not so much manager-orientated but purpose orientated. then has we've got to set up some systems for that to operate?

Let's talk about what are these systems because broadly we're talking concretely, what does the manager need to do in order to fundamentally implement where you're talking about? I've looked at lots of different models of what makes effective teams and i'd be working with teams for twenty-five years as an independent consultant. And I think the simplest way to talk about these is just have this three fundamental foundational bases that Managers must look at and there's two extensions so a total of five.

So the three fundamental bases that must be covered for a Manager to start working create a team. That shares power with one another where they're not using their authority ineffectively And getting in the way, so they want to get out of the way of their team? The first base is this. I've mentioned it before but the team will need to clarify what its shared purpose is. It will need to clarify what it Now, and I've discussed that all five in my book bosses behaving badly because if bosses behave really well with teams then this is the first thing they'll do.

In my book i put in a script That a boss can follow If they want to facilitate meeting which helps The group talk about what our shared highest priorities are. We need come together on as team. So and when I'm working with executive teams, I often start this question. What is it that you as a team can do? That no other team could? well? If we didn't do it then there would be problems for the organization And so i've asked many senior teams these questions pull together their thoughts and we group them, cluster with the top three to four priorities for them as a team.

And then when they come together They know here are the top things that should be discussed. other thing should have been less priority. So if you don't have those high-priority veneer in my experience what I end up doing is spending endless hours updating eachother on what all their departments are doing and update, update kill me with another update. you know they...and so I teach the groups to do sixty second updates from each person. then we're done with updates.

Then we just share information as needed You know? And there's updates or the team gets pulled into some kind of Some kind of juicy thing to talk about. that's really not the business at the whole team to be doing. It's actually inherent in someone his job there. But it gets pulled into the team and for better or worse. They're not just discussing that. And so all of course crises. they'll just do the work on crises.

Right, so you talk about focus really need to focus. what is it we're doing here? What does that can-do? hear? well? You know...what is the uniqueness of our time together? rather than gossip in some sense something juicy or a drama or all the updates. you know personal I kind of yeah like way too focused at him and obviously Yeah, and it needs to. A manager can help a group stay focused not on themselves. but what's our mission here?

And I mean our mission as a team! What is that team mission? Sometimes when they ask the question of executive members They'll give me back their whole organisation mission. It's like well thats important you know that. But what does your team do? Oh god, I don't know. What do we do? Well... We look at a lot of numbers and figure out if the organisation is winning or not. Is no one else doing that? The whole finance department does it too But we spent a lot of time as well.

You know what I mean? It's it's like wow, okay. So what is that you guys would do about those numbers and nobody else would do? And so yeah its very important question. now the other one-on-one this goes on to is The Question Of Norms. This Is Remarkably Important. Can A team Simply Agree on the way that we want to engage each other while we go about doing our vision and working at our mission. In one piece of research, they looked at a hundred...

I'll mention this again in just a moment actually later with One Of The Other Bases will cover. but team norms was whether the team had clarified what their was. simply the single most predictive factor on whether a team is an effective executive team in this case. Wow! It's amazing, it's amazing. The most predictive of if there were to be an effective Executive Team leading And if not measured by whether the team actually felt good about one another, measured by weather their whole organization was functioning and effective and profitable.

All appropriate means of measurement there.". It turned out that it was Team Norms. This was really helpful because when if you the team can identify The top three or four five ways in which it wants to talk with one another then It creates an immune system within the team to To stop the unhelpful problematic insidiously toxic and negative ways of working with one another. And it can help the team take on a collective accountability to uphold the way we like to talk, work with each other.

It's great use power for managers. in my book I give a script facilitate a team to within in half an hour or one hour at the most, agree to what their team norms are. And that elevates the functioning of the team and means that when one person starts to behave In ways that others are finding very hard and problematic It's not just up with the boss to take them aside. The whole team can do it because we've all agreed on this.

Yes That's right. It's a critical thing, Vinay. Then the whole team becomes accountable for creating a team that observes their norms. and until you have norms You can have I was talking with someone recently And i haven't started working With this executive Team yet? one particular person who's just behaving in ways that the rest of people are finding really problematic. And so it has become an undiscussable topic for the team and nobody knows whether they've got a right to raise it, why isn't there bus talking?

And so they just go to the kind of like well, you know that boss isn't doing. what can we do? Like there? out here It's it's like. Well I can wait to work with norms With this group and then we can talk about What are the behaviors that a really tolerable water intolerable and how Do we talk with one another when one of us behaves in ways which are not okay or presents A problem? yeah That's a little bit like in a previous episode. were talking about groups, we're talking about the power index. it was and the importance of a leader holding space and creating safety, that was it.

That's what you're talking about. Safety is created by these kind of norms And some of the norms need to be around limits to behaviors which are destructive into personally or group or mission. It's surprising You would think those wouldn't be established. yet as you say sometimes they don't get established and so the group is sort of loose or it loses momentum, or doesn't know how to deal with problematic people in the group.

And then you know as people can get ostracized or something rather than explicitly saying well okay let's make it up front what's ok? What's not OK? Then How do we deal with that? Here's an example and lets apply! So its creating some sort of orderly framework. basically Yes. Yeah, absolutely right and I was at first shocked with that research finding. but then...I just realised it's really the beginning. It is very foundational.

A team can't get about its mission unless they are prepared to work in ways where we stay engaged. And if someone or people within the team are routinely doing things which seem entirely counter to creating a collective problem-solving space, or field between them and it can't be discussed then we have a problem. Sometimes behavior is actually the boss's behaviour... ...and norms gives increased empowerment for their team.

That's right, that is very important. Without norms it is difficult for the team to have a basis upon which to raise certain behaviours. So let us go on with the final pillar. what are you talking about? I referenced some research moments ago and this same research had fascinating findings of one hundred twenty executive teams across multiple you know countries and only seven percent of those teams all agreed on who was actually in the executive team.

Seven percent! It's boggling, I don't even know. how does that work? Who is it working for?! And so i'm not the only one who wrote a model that includes membership. others have as well because membership turns out to be a really critical way for a team to create boundaries and we know who's in, whose out. And then creates safety within that. but until you actually clear whos'in, whos out? One of the reasons is because In an executive team often You might have someone come-in Who sort of...

Who assists or advises Or one of the Executive Team members reportees comes with critical information who the rest of team seems to need, hear from and then they just start coming every meeting. And that happens with somebody else before you know it. we don't really because there's certain people who are sort of turning up all the time. And I imagine, and i've seen this in various contexts too that sometimes someone whose nominally a member You know, like they're busy.

They have meetings There's more important things and-and they don't show up that much. so there is this place kept for them as a team member but then most of the time their not theirs. So thats also kind of confusing because its a sort of theoretical member. I've been in teams like that And it was kinda annoying cause. after awhile you were like well they dont really seem to be part of his team. Its annoying! Absolutely, I like the way you put that.

They're a theoretical member. You know they have their idea but are they? It wasn't so long ago that i can't remember it quite clearly and i was facilitating this particular team. there were around nine of them maybe ten Maybe nine. We got to morning tea time And its just dawning on me The first day when we worked with him. There is person in group that actually wasn't a member of the team and we were about to get into some of the tensions operating within them.

We started doing more sensitive work, then I approached someone in my team who said hey could you just clarify? Who's THAT person?! And they said oh yeah! That person he reports to that team member there...and i said Oh okay so does anyone else have any of their reportees here at the meeting? No Well, oh so maybe this was discussed earlier. Do you know why that person did? Oh no idea I don't know why they're here You know. and then Then i went there to the boss And said we are about To get into some sensitive areas in About ten minutes.

But im curious Why is That Person There In This Team? Because They Actually Don't Report To You. They Report One Of The Members And Im Just Wondering. And The Boss Said I Dont Know Why They Are Here And it was just like no one, everyone felt a little bit shy to say excuse me what are you doing here? and so I then said okay well we're not going. If I just want to let you know, I'm going to go and approach the person's manager.

And ask them to speak with him about letting me know that we appreciate their time is not required moving forward in this meeting.". The boss went oh god okay! Okay! The boss didn't wanna upset anyone. Wow! Yeah but... Oh and i said yeah.. You're ok? Ok so when did that manager say by the way your team members here? I'm not sure why they're here. Maybe you could say something, because this meeting is specifically for those who report to the boss in...

Oh! And then that gave me some... You know what? The meeting was about X and so i brought this team maybe cause they knew more of it than anybody else. I'd like you just to let them know that we appreciate their willingness to comment. They're not required anymore for any further fitness meeting and they looked at me. one word really? And i said yes, I would like you do yeah well... You are playing the role of manager by putting the boundaries in and clearly whoever that person is didn't have imposter syndrome.

So anyway, that happened and we went on to doing it. And membership is important because were going to discuss some really sensitive things there. That person was about get insight into all sorts of tendencies that happen within this team. that didn't necessarily happens in any other teams. It wasn't appropriate for random member of another team to be there Simply because it was somehow awkward and people felt shy To do so. membership.

So It's a really important piece, so should we go then too? Yes, that yes, let's. yeah, so I know after we got stage you'll we go to these last two pieces And one of them is about decision-making and the other is about learning And the first one about Decision Maker, or really more appropriately. It's about how we solve problems together and I in my experience have found it that most teams... ...it's useful if they discuss together How They Solve Problems Because If You Don't you'll just Have Whatever Kind of Default Half Baked kind Of Mechanism Occurs In A Team When They Try To Solve a Problem.

And teams don't solve problems as often we might like. They get into all sorts of updates, they discuss sort-of issues but they often do not want to know what it is that's going on about them and rarely talk about the causes of a problem. or if you can understand I know in my book and i teach this to many teams the principles of divergence before convergence on solution, gathering information then analyzing whatever decision might be informed.

As long as their decision-making process honors divergence before convergence, and we don't have people trying to generate options while others are trying to push us through solution... And create internal tensions around that? That's often what is happening in teams. We'll need to talk explicitly about Are we right now divergent or gathering data or are we converging with analysis and moving to a decision. And I talk about that as a kite, so i have the kite methodology which is in this book. but independent of the kite methodology i recommend teams consider how they solve problems because if you don't then it's left open to be taken ransom by whatever power play. individuals in the team, including their manager may wish... ...to apply on a group around making decisions and solving problems.

And then learning being last one is where the group gets to pause and reflect back on itself. How are we going? Are we orientated round our mission? Is that membership clear? How are we going with our problem solving? Are we talking, are moving in the direction that most want to move as a team. This is where the teams must have times when they pause and reflect upon itself so as to gain more effective or better. A team should be affected by moments of meta on its own activity, its own behaviour.

Like an individual. obviously we've talked before about the necessity of self-reflection and a diamond index. We're talking about that. Self reflection, self awareness And then feedback from others those are two things That Are important. so here? We're Talking About interesting on Team Level. who are we as A team? what's our definition? What's Our membership? or do we doing Here? you know how Do we solve problems and You Know Fundamentally How Can We Continue Learning on a team level about that.

So it's really engaging in, uh-in a team levels. self reflection Yeah spot on. and this is what enables the team to be able to continue to exercise power. well um To exercise the collective power That The Team can create by its shared problem solving And Its ability to access all of the intelligences Of the individuals enhance it through a collective focus and then go out, take action based on that. And to be able to utilize power well with each other and beyond the team...

The notion of being able to reflect on that is central for a team being able functioned well moving forward sustainably and so the learning base that I suggest is covered by teams, it's very much a question of reflecting on how are we going together? And now were using out incredible possibility this collective power. We can create field to have when you come together and can bring intention into their fields. what is our mission?

And then how can that inform our conversations and our actions moving forward? Very good. Well to wrap up, I guess we're again bringing you back to the listener or the watcher and inviting you. So I consider teams that are a part of, whether you manage how these different conditions might operate there what would score low on? What your team would score lower one therefore it is that you need to clarify And then bring up at next-team meeting To focus. so It's not just leading into boss but as a team member You can also raise this type topic.

In fact sense lead from underneath? Oh, yes. You know and I put in the book Bosses Behaving Badly a short questionnaire of five questions for each base so that you can rate your own team! And The Team Can Rate Itself In Terms Of How Well We Are Operating As We Share Power And Exercise Power Together. Yeah. So i recommend That To Anybody Who Wants to A Quick litmus tests on how well their team is functioning.