Episode 08The Psychology of Leadership and Influence

Leadership Triggers, Shame and Emotional Intelligence

What really happens when a leader gets triggered? How shame drives our reactions, and a five-step method to interrupt them.

Episode 8 — Leadership Triggers, Shame and Emotional Intelligence
In this episode
  • Why a “trigger” is really an old stress reminding itself in the present moment
  • How leaders unconsciously use their rank to self-soothe when triggered
  • The crucial difference between shame (“I am a mistake”) and guilt (“I made a mistake”)
  • A real coaching story: the CEO blindsided by his team's hidden shame
  • Introducing TRACE: Track, Regulate, Analyse, Choose, Engage
  • Simple grounding techniques — breathing and small movement — to regulate in the moment
  • Why naming your triggers to your team can build trust, not weakness

Drs. Vinay and Paul explore triggers — those unexpected reminders of past stress that hijack our behaviour in the present — and how leaders unconsciously use their rank to self-soothe when triggered, from barking orders to withdrawing. They distinguish shame (“I am a mistake”) from guilt (“I made a mistake”), and share a real coaching story of a CEO blindsided by his team's shame around a failed project. They introduce TRACE — Track, Regulate, Analyse, Choose, Engage — a practical five-step method for interrupting trigger patterns, alongside simple grounding techniques like breathing and small movements.

Chapters

01Welcome and Episode Overview: Power, Shame, and Triggers

00:00:00

02Understanding Triggers: Definitions and Leadership Impact

00:00:29

03The Psychology of Triggers: Anxiety, Power, and Self-Soothing

00:04:06

04Shame vs. Guilt: The Hidden Drivers of Leadership Behavior

00:13:33

05Real-World Leadership: Shame in Executive Teams

00:17:00

06Practical Tools: The TRACE Model for Managing Triggers

00:19:46

07Regulation in Action: Breathing, Grounding, and Team Support

00:25:02

08Building Power With Others: Humility and Collective Leadership

00:31:15
Full transcript

Auto-generated transcript (speech-to-text). Speaker labels not included; minor transcription errors may be present.

So, welcome everyone to the next episode of our Power Podcast. I'm Dr. Stephen Aganta with Dr. Paul Donovan. we're both experts in power very interested in the topic and uh...we enjoy talking about it. so today yeah.. We are going be talking about issues to do which shame And to do with triggers and what to do about because were interested in introducing the ideas, the concepts as well as illustrating them and then giving you something that you can concretely do.

Yes absolutely! You know triggers which is the focus of this time together we have today for me one of the most gritty most important topics leaders can work with. I mean it was a lot of decades ago that Stephen Covey said first comes the private victory than the public. And in my mind, The Private Victory is won by a decision to look at one's triggers, Vinay? That's what I think and...and i-I think it's a big part of how our leader grows from the inside out!

It's how a leader ultimately uses the immense power in the most authentic and the most powerful, the most effective manner. And a huge part of this is looking at our triggers and behaving less driven and informed by our triggers. What do you think? Yes Triggers are something that everyone's familiar with not just people in positions or power. certainly I do couples therapy. We all know we get triggered in a relationship and an intimate relationship.

And one of the things that I'm often dealing with is what's called a trigger-trigger situation where both people are triggered, and then it just kind of arm again. nobody who calm everything provoked. So i think well you're familiar With that. certainly part of development not only leadership. Certainly any personal development Is also very much about being aware Of ways to get triggered and knowing what to do about it.

Shall I just start with what i think could be a useful definition of a trigger? Yes please okay um A Trigger is, Is a moment where we get unexpectedly reminded Of our past circumstance Where were under pressure or stress And in that moment which Triggered and inverted commas by what someone says in this present day like there's Someone could say something do something. a particular Circumstance that might surround you at that moment Unexpectedly reminds your brain of a past circumstance.

And then as a result when we get triggered. We go into usually a fight or flight of some kind. We're in stress. Our limbic system, a relatively primitive part of our brain compared to the more sophisticated six millimeter neocortex that's going over the top starts to exert often more control over thoughts feelings and behaviors than we would like And we behave in ways That are triggered by the pain or stress That has been triggered by the initial circumstance, but actually our brain is reliving something that's happened some time earlier and And we ultimately end up behaving in ways that are inappropriate for the present moment But make sense In the context of a previous stress.

How does that land? What? how did I go over name? yeah. Yeah well my course. as a therapist i'm very interested in this whole topic. Actually, back in my early twenties I was studying clowning and theater. And it had a very interesting teacher who kind of introduced you could say psychological concepts... He made this distinction between what he called present-time emotion and banker motion which is very relevant if your studying theatre because the whole method acting about bringing up emotions so helped us understand that A present time emotion, whether it's sadness or anger is your reaction to what's going on right now.

Whereas when you call the bank emotion as You say things that you pull from the bank and those emotions tend To be more unwieldy they tend to be heavier They tend to often be a bit inappropriate to the president. So that's the first thing I think of. The second thing Is that um major element Whether it'd been a power role or leadership role Triggered in that situation, or whether it be an interpersonal trigger is anxiety.

And although some people don't identify as being anxious and some people are more obviously anxious than others I think anxiety Is something that we all kind of deal with at a time especially in this kind of triggering situation That you're talking about? Anxiety is the very important thing to understand In relation to power. Yes It truly is. In my experience, most misuse of power by leaders is simply them having the unfortunate experience are being in an elevated position but feeling frustrated upset getting triggered.

So you've got low rank feelings that your inner position have high ranked And that combination is highly problematic. That disjuncture is highly problematic because what we tend to do, Vinay ,is utilize the rank To give us cover to behave in certain ways so that we can start to feel better again. and In the most obvious example, I can think of right now when a leader uses their rank to bark orders at their team or close down conversations.

They've momentarily got stressed about something they have got triggered by something that's happened in the meeting and they've utilized the rank of their role to unilaterally decide we gotta move on or that we've got to speed up, all the way should stop talking about this. So although we need to dive deeper into it and analyze something that needs happened on the leader will then just take over in a sense and doing so disempower others. but primarily when they're gaining here is if you get momentary relief from whatever triggered them.

And so this is the anatomy of poor power use, as leaders who are being unconsciously prompted from one trigger to another. when they get scared or anxious, or stressed about something and then engage in a behavior that gives them momentary relief. And the behaviour they're engaging is usually one that's made...that they have access to because their'e in leadership role! You know it was no different for parents. we got triggered by some thing happening which may not have anything do with our kids but beacause our kid has difficulty challenging us up until i get certain age You know, we may yell raise our voice or detach ourselves.

Or do something which gives us momentary relief about whatever's causing stress will just behave in what ever context We can. where? We've got the authority to do something that gives us immediate relief and rank gives Us. That Rank Gives Us more behavioral options that we Can Do Without Being Called on Yeah Yeah. In terms of psychological term, we'd use the word soothing or self-soothing. and certainly if you think about it like as a child is having a child, child becomes distressed then we want to find ways to soothe the child.

I mean some parents will soothe their child by...I don't know these days giving them screen on something but really what's necessary is that they need calm down in the best kind calming being emotionally present. now given many of us don't experience that in childhood when we're distressed, then our own self-soothing mechanisms might be any number or what would call creative adjustments which might be disassociating all sorts of things.

We do to cope with the stress and anxiety but as you say if your in a position for power Fundamentally, what we're saying is that the mechanism underneath them. Is this kind of self soothing and a lot of leaders can get away without Recognizing things but that's going on. they think well This is appropriate or I'm under boss saw these people are stupid Or whatever it isn't not really be looking at themselves. So what?

We're talking about here And in many other things were discussing about power is the willingness of leaders to look at themselves, to look their own internal dynamics and behavior. And be willing step back review it open doing something different because that's trouble. a lot of leaders become very rigid fixed in these kind of patterns. often if you ask them they're anxious probably say what are talking about? They'll be insulted or something. yeah this That's right.

They sometimes don't even know they're anxious, it's evidence of their lack of self-examination. and so this is where I think as the richest overlap between leadership in therapy. And you know many leaders would balk at The idea what do i need to go To a therapist or become A good leader like What? You Know Like. It can seem like an almost crazy idea. And I'm not suggesting that everyone needs to necessarily go to a therapist, but the work one does with a therapist when you're looking at what's triggering you and how...and your taking responsibility for your triggered behavior?

Yeah! That's also the work of leadership. If we've got more power available to us through the roles we occupy, then we must step up. To being prepared to do the work on our triggers and if not will just become all the other leaders that were poked a finger at instead. look at that jerk. you know how. aren't they ridiculous? They're just behaving so badly And before we know it where that leader? And what I say before we not, We don't know it usually.

It happens and we're unaware that we've become that leader simply because of the unwillingness to win the private victory first at least concurrently. so there's a very important overlap here. And you know, Vinay that's one of the reasons why you and I love talking about power. because if your going to be in roles with more power then it is a great trigger in effect. To start doing this work its'a flagged say You better start doing these works Because If Your Don't As The Demands Of Your Roll Increase You Will Get Under More Pressure You'll Get Triggered More And you'll get triggered with all your past experiences of stress.

They're just going to continue to re-get retriggered and then You'll get into these compensatory reactions, which will almost certainly Mean you or be engaging in aren't in terrible misuses of power? Exactly So let's talk about the role of shame here because we talked about anxiety. now The roller down would talk about shame. now shame is a a very big topic, it's something. although people may recognise some degree of anxiety I think there is less recognition or shame in the role that plays.

Partly because you could say shame was like the most uncomfortable experience and generally we all of us certainly might experience personally And nobody wants to feel ashamed. It's an awful experience. People would do anything to not feel it and certainly, not recognize that. And yet along with anxiety It's a kind of a core driver. So maybe we can just talk about this? The first thing I think is good To talk about Is making this issue between shame and guilt Because sometimes people use those words interchangeably But they actually are different.

Yeah They ARE different! Um...I've had the experience where i have been overcome shame at certain moments. Most of us have, haven't we Vinay? And and you know one of the distinctions is guilt might be I've made a mistake. Shame is way more global it is. i am a mistake. It's I can't...I'm utterly unworthy! I am inadequate..i'm not enough. and sinking into that Experience and one can you know, like you an I have talked about the shame dungeon because it can encapsulate.

You and hold your you can circle around in shame sometimes And shame can by nature of itself become a very disempowering experience whereby we don't even know or don't We consider ourselves as not having this strength to climb out of the shame itself. so we're trapped And, you know when we get uncovered to behave badly. It's one thing that say I've behaved badly but it is another think oh my God! I am so wrong...I'm so wrong.

Yeah and thats why leaders don't want go there. Nobody really does. certainly as a leadership position of the power can change focus or do things move away from feeling shame. I mean, we all do that. It's just it sort of exaggerated by the leadership and the power issue. And i guess something else That i wanted to say about um shame is that Often people feel shame or triggered into shame By the behavior of someone who has power over them a teacher Or a boss or something Who can shame them?

Say that was The stupid thing you did. You know how could you make that mistake? or you Know i don't really want you part Of this meeting. There's lots of ways that people can use power to shame others, you know, inadvertently but sometimes intentionally. However what's interesting I think in this context is even in a leadership position You still experience shame. So for instance uh...you give an order and i want you do it And the person maybe does passive aggressive thing. they'll be like yes then find yourself nagging them As a leader, it's kind of very embarrassing to be nagging an employee and you start feeling angry or angry because they're not doing what you want.

Or sometimes the sassy employee can make a sharp retort that a lead is not really ready for And kinda gets in there despite the toughness or the protectiveness as role. Yes! There's this shame reaction. when someone get shamed The first thing they tend to do is, They want a shame back. So that's where you get in shame cycles with couples very badly but also In this power differential. so there are A lot of dynamics about Shame which Are Very important To understand and be aware Of.

You know That just so true. One of the experiences I've had With leaders in shame Is The vulnerability a leader will have. When i sit down with a team Like often when i sit Down with executive teams I know that the most vulnerable person in the room will be the boss of that team, you CEO. Because it's possible things we'll get discussed. In fact entirely likely Things would get discussed in a different manner because i'm in The Room and there is a facilitator And I remember not so long ago working with an executive Team. they were discussing how They worked on this particular project and I was supporting them to debrief This work.

As it turns out of the six people in the executive team excluding the CEO five thought that they'd done a really, really ordinary job That they thought that had really done A very poor job on this project. It was pretty critical and The CEO In This Case Was The One Primarily Driving It Driving The Project. Well The CEO Was Very Uncomfortable About This. Now To His Credit Um, he didn't react back there in the meeting too much.

I looked to support him in the meaning because that could see that this you know was... Because i'd given voice To The Team In A Way That They Hadn't Had a Voice Before To Discuss This Project. If Frankly Wasn'T A Conversation The CEO Had Facilitated Before He Had Agreed To The Conversation Before I Walked Into The Room He And I But He Been really kind of sidestepped by the conversation and been rather shocked. But I do know that CEO had great apprehensions about having me back in the room again, you know what i mean when they like. yes it was really tough. he's gracious but there is a part of him who said I will never let this happen because he experienced shame And it was, and I get who amongst us hasn't been in his position.

I really felt that he did talk him by surprise. He didn't think he was going to but it was plain to me. He felt some shame and So It was a difficult experience. The group was uncomfortable. We talked about that as well But they were really pleased To be able to speak plainly About this with each other and With the CEO. They didn't talk in a blameful manner, that's for sure. I was in the room and guiding the conversation but the leader himself yeah um felt a lot of shame about that project not running to. you know he thought that the thing had all gone really well.

And uh so his team didn't think so. So it can happen. Let's talk about what people can do about this. Sure okay let's do that. Hey i've got a little model. Vinay reflected on and use myself, clients that I've had have used. And it's not a bad way of summarizing also what we talked about in relation to triggers. So here is the word track And each letter stands for something. So the first letter T stands for track, you and I know track what is triggering us?

Track it! We don't have to wait for the circumstances to occur even. You can do this work before the triggers happen, you can reflect on what's triggered you in the past and begin to examine What are the scenarios? The words and tone And actions, the situations that tend to trigger. track it. build awareness of It. as Dr. Julie Diamond says Burn your wood. So when you burn your wood, You're not so much like a big pile of dry timber ready to go up with the nearest spark, you're already burnt.

You've burned your wood so less easily triggered. So burn your wood beforehand. spend time looking at your triggers writing down what triggered and what went through your mind And how you behaved that moment. just allow for increased awareness. That's T for Track. The R from Trace is Regulate At this point when are experiencing trigger trigger, become aware of it and just put a wedge in there. Just widen the space between the trigger and your next action.

Regulate. usually that's done best by breathing. breathe. Breathe into one's belly, don't take a shoulder breath or what we call a clavicular. Like that but rather breathe in to ones belly because it sends an immediate message through your whole body That you're actually not In major threat right now Because you are NOT. You're actually the threat you're experiencing in your body when you trigger is Not What We Think It Is Right Vinay?

It's just not so. regulate. A in Trace is Analyze. So you may or not be able to do that at the moment, but what's happening here? What's triggering me? What behavior is it? What meaning am I making out of this?". You do a little bit of analysis and just enough for your then-to-do list C which is Choose. This Disjuncture the first three letters are about building the capacity To understand what's going on to build agency to breathe to analyze.

See is choose here. Is where we do a behavior, which is different to the one that our usual triggering pattern would prompt. and by The way remember it is a patent. this is not a one-off It's not something That's just gonna happen once or Not. all triggers Unique. most of them are simply just Patterns of triggers that we usually get but we have been triggered before and were likely to get triggered again. It's a pattern, and that's why it's work.

That We can do so choose To behave differently. at that moment ask one selves A different question like what? Do I want to create here? or What my purpose? What's my purpose? Those two questions can help us choose a new behavior. And the last letter E being in Trace says, okay then act lean into your new chosen behaviour. so trace is great little mnemonic to help work with our triggers track regulate analyze choose engage.

You could. you can also replace engage with well, I mean examine. I think another e-word which is the examined life. Yes about that and certainly anybody in that person's personal growth field Is interested in this question to examine life? And that's exactly what we're talking about. whilst a CEO might not jump into Therapy or things at they need therapy particularly really. What were talking about as kind of reflectiveness there?

Therapy engages because that's what we do in all these cases. We're attending, were bringing awareness to whats going on. Self-awareness and awareness of dynamics where especially regulated I think is very important Because it's all very well to have some cognitive recognition. Oh yeah i get triggered by this situation but you know Also indipersibly...we can have self knowledge. But my wife says something. or you know, the kids there's something a teenager particularly.

And then we're triggered. so their regulation is very important. You mentioned breathing and that's something... We work with a lot in therapy. It's something anybody can learn to do more of better. I was just teaching a weekend some students therapeutic instruction weekends. So often did somebody be triggered they start crying or The anger be triggered, and the first thing I often say is take a breath. because the first things that people do as they freeze up.

Emotions too intense They don't know how to handle it or historically they've been overwhelmed so... That they tense-up And then there's no movement possible. So yeah breathe! And students were kind of laughing at this bit about this Because thats' often the First Thing. i say Take A Breath! And then another thing That's wonderful. I bet you were wonderful with them, that just sounds great! What a weekend... It was fun and i did some supervision too when the students came up And it kind of funny because they're like their clients getting upset.

They are like, ah breathe! That is great! Breathe That's great. Yeah, when in doubt breathe. yeah I couldn't agree more. the number of times i've taught this to facilitators When moments happen In meetings and i'll say i will...i don't need To do it anymore. but when i started Years ago i would put my hand down on My belly And push my belly out with an inhale Exactly! And then knowing that i was doing abdominal breath Knowing that sending a massive signals to my brain That everything is actually okay.

Exactly, and you know that's often what I tell people to put your hand on your tummy And breathe into your hands. now the other one The same one more thing about regulate because uh-huh important ingredient. another is a very simple One because what happens? Is that when we get overwhelmed in particularly shame or other triggering emotions We tend to in a way leave our body there's the freezing and then Often what people do as they just disassociate like they kind of go into some spacey world or into an entirely mental frame.

So to re-inhabit the body, it's good to do simple things like kind of wiggle your toes. you can be in a meeting nobody is going to notice really bring yourself down onto your feet that very grounding literally Or just move your shoulders get some mobility into there because the freezing is what tends to happen physically and then emotionally. so if we want regulate the breathing, the movement. These simple things you know nobody's going to worry if you kind of rotate your head or get yourself a bit comfortable and just those little movements can restore the body...can do a bit of a reset.

Yes! Fabulous fabulous they're all Under. ah, you know the regulate absolutely right now. How do we re-regulate? how Do we how do we soothe ourselves? How do We regulate our nervous system back into The appropriate balance between sympathetic and and parasympathetic nervous systems for those who understand that language Because when they're triggered were likely to be in a sympathetic nervous system of fight-and-flight. but Those are wonderful tools to help rebalance our autonomic nervous system, the parasympathetic and sympathetic to enable us to have a truly resourceful effective response.

To the present moment. And that's what goes missing when we're triggered because we still reacting to a past experience but doing it in. And so yeah, there's I think something we could probably add in here that We have mentioned before. We did a whole piece on feedback. But i think it was also relevant Here because the openness to knowing your triggers and identifying them even Stepping out of the shame bind and telling Your team or the executives who are around you look these are places That I tend To lose It?

You might Have seen that some kind of help, you know. It's a humble position but just to put that out there means we dispel the shame in way by naming it and owning it. And choosing can be also choosing. get support from other people on this place. That humility is probably likely go down well I imagine with employees or peers. Absolutely If a leader can balance the notion of bringing humility and still knowing at other times, they'll have to step out and say tough things.

Lead bravely in a direction that I actually feel is not entirely certain or confront someone with underperformance. all those things are still required but there it when when the moment demands it. And there are some moments, like the ones you've just been discussing today where humility and letting your team in on the moments that might tend to trigger you may need a hand. That is for me It's always territory I'm looking. support an executive team move toward Where everyone knows What it is. that Is the place where they've each.

Each person there's a little vulnerable or may start to react Or get into unhelpful sets of behaviors. Exactly, yeah You know That's that's The place we're ahead in When I'm working with an executive team and that's the Place Where They can be way more effective And lead better as A collective. Yeah so That's where we're coming today. The basic thesis is how can you move from just exerting the power over to the power with, which has obviously most effective means of power and this an important ingredient in that mechanism?

Yeah absolutely triggers it. a fabulously important topic To raise in relation using Powerwell And I'm glad We've talked about It Today. Wonderful Well. See You Next Episode!